Hey Sammi — Win the Week
Episode 27August 13, 20267 minutes 17 seconds

My kid’s teammate just got recruited at 14, does that mean my daughter is behind?

Short answer

Your kid is not behind just because a teammate committed at 14. Early commitments are mostly informal, often fall apart, and have zero impact on your daughter’s real development. The only timeline that matters is her own, growth, character, and love for the game beat some internet version of "ahead" every time.

Comparison is the fastest way to stop loving anything.

Questions this episode answers

  • What do I say when my daughter feels "behind" after seeing a teammate commit to college at 14?
  • Is it normal for kids to get recruited so young, or are those early commitments rare and unstable?
  • How can I help my kid focus on her own progress instead of comparing herself to teammates online?
  • What can I do at home to protect my daughter from the pressure and self-doubt that comes from scrolling through recruiting posts?

Sammi's Take

Is my kid behind if her teammate committed to college at 14?

That post hit like a punch. Your daughter’s teammate, beaming in a college hoodie, COMMITTED, and suddenly your living room gets quieter. She’s 14, for crying out loud. Your kid is two years into braces and already worried she missed the boat.

Let’s turn down the heat. That hoodie? It isn’t a signed contract. Early commitments at 14 are rare, usually not official, and get walked back all the time. Coaches change schools. Kids’ bodies change. Offers disappear. None of that makes it into the Instagram post, of course, those only ever show the shiny beginnings, never the uncommitments that follow.

The reality: the recruiting industry knows attention is the new currency. That commitment post is marketing, not a finish line. But your daughter is treating it like a scorecard, convinced she’s trailing in a race nobody told her she was running.

“Behind” on what schedule?

Ask her. Really, behind on whose timeline? There’s no “schedule” for getting recruited. The internet’s favorite storyline is that every college athlete knew their destiny at age 13. The rosters? They say otherwise. Full of late bloomers, kids who barely noticed recruiting until high school, got serious at 16, and overtook the early stars.

Progress in sports is not a straight line; it’s a scribble. The girls who make it? They aren’t the first ones to post a commitment. They’re the ones who stubbornly keep loving the game, long enough to get good at it. Comparison is the fastest way to stop loving it, and that’s the real danger, not missing a made-up deadline.

What should I say to my kid?

Forget “don’t worry, you’re not behind.” That bounces off a teenager’s skull like a rubber ball. Try evidence. Sit with her and pull out a blank sheet of paper. Write one thing she can do now that she couldn’t six months ago. First touch? Reading the game? Her coach letting her take the left side? If she’s busy tracking teammates online, she probably missed the ways she’s gotten better.

And yes, talk about the feed. The commitment posts, recruiting hype, endless highlight reels, a slot machine for self-doubt. You can’t lock her out of her phone, but you can name it for what it is. Ask how she feels after 20 minutes scrolling. Kids know. Feeling behind after that exercise? That isn’t a red flag about her game, it’s a giant signal about the feed itself.

Am I feeding the comparison monster too?

Let’s be honest, this stuff is contagious. If you find yourself refreshing club rankings or talking about which eighth grader got an offer, she catches your anxiety before the algorithm gets a shot. The house sets the scoreboard. Make your scoreboard count things she can actually control: effort, courage, that one hard pass she finally tried.

And for a bonus life skill, help her send a real, honest congratulatory text to her teammate. Not because it’s polite. Because envy shrinks when it has to say congratulations out loud, and that girl in the hoodie is still her friend, underneath the social media fog.

If your daughter genuinely wants to play college ball someday, the work that matters at 14 isn’t exposure. It’s skills. Strength. Grades. And keeping the pilot light lit for as long as it takes.

So put one line on the bathroom mirror: “One thing I can do now that I couldn’t do six months ago.” That’s it. Quiet, un-Instagrammable, and actually true.

If you’re fighting off the comparison monster, you’re not the only one. The feed only shows the start of the story. Keep your eyes on the middle.

Tired of juggling six sports apps? Put Sammi to work

Episode transcript

Read full transcript

The post went up on a Tuesday. Her teammate in a college hoodie, big block letters: COMMITTED. Fourteen years old. And your daughter has been quiet ever since, doing math in her head that nobody assigned her. She thinks she's late to a race she just started.

I'm Sammy, and you found the Hey Sammy Podcast. One real letter a day from a real sports parent, answered the way a friend would.

Today, recruiting at 14, and the comparison spiral it sets off in every other kid on the roster. This one's from Angela in Raleigh. She writes, "My daughter's teammate is getting recruited already, and she's only 14. Now my daughter thinks she's behind. How do I talk to her about this?"

Angela, let's start with what that hoodie post actually is. Because it's a lot less than it looks like. Early commitments at 14 are rare, mostly informal, and reversed all the time. Coaches change jobs. Offers evaporate. Bodies and games change enormously between 14 and 18.

The recruiting industry has stretched its timeline earlier and earlier because attention is the product. That post is marketing. Your daughter is treating it like a rankings list.

Now, the word "behind." I want you to help her interrogate it, because it falls apart under one question: behind on what schedule? There's no schedule. There's a story the internet tells where every scholarship kid was anointed at 13.

The real rosters tell a different one. They're full of late bloomers who got serious at 16 and passed the early stars. Development isn't a line. It's, um, a scribble. And here's the part that matters most: the girls who make it aren't the ones who commit first. They're the ones who keep loving the game long enough to get good at it.

Comparison is the fastest way to stop loving anything. So how do you actually talk to her? Not with, "don't worry about it, you're not behind." Reassurance bounces off a 14-year-old. Evidence doesn't.

Sit with her and build the only comparison that means anything: her versus her from six months ago. What can she do now that she couldn't do in the spring? Be specific. Her first touch, her left side, her reading of the game, her minutes... Watch her face while the list grows. That's what progress actually looks like, and she's been too busy scrolling to see her own.

Speaking of scrolling... The commitment posts, the recruiting accounts, the highlight reels, that feed is a slot machine for teenage self-doubt. You can't ban it, she's 14. But you can name it. I have a rule at my house: no rankings talk at the dinner table. And I extend it to my own phone.

Ask her how she feels after 20 minutes on that feed. Kids can tell. Feeling behind after scrolling isn't information about her game, it's information about the feed.

And Angela, do a quiet check on the adult side of the car too. Comparison is contagious, and kids catch it from us before they catch it from any feed. If we're, um, refreshing club rankings or asking about other girls' offers, she notices.

The house sets the scoreboard. Make yours measure things she can control. Effort. Courage. Whether she tried the hard pass.

When the house scoreboard is sane, the internet one loses its power. And one more truth for your back pocket: four years from now, half those early commitments will have quietly unraveled. Nobody posts the uncommitment. The feed only shows beginnings. Never the middles.

Oh, and one small thing with a long reach: help her congratulate the teammate. For real. A text, a hug at practice, something true. Not because it's polite. Because envy shrinks when it has to say congratulations out loud and mean it.

That girl in the hoodie is still her friend underneath all of this. Comparison tried to turn a teammate into a measuring stick. Turn her back into a person.

And if she really does want to play in college someday, tell her this: The work that matters at 14 isn't exposure. It's skills, strength, grades, and keeping the fire lit. Exposure finds prepared players. It rarely works the other way around.

Your homework this week is one line on paper. Have her write down one thing she does better than she did six months ago. Stick it on the bathroom mirror. Done.

And that's the episode. Somebody in your bleachers is quietly fighting the comparison monster too. Send them this one.

Questions go to hey@heysami.com.

About the Hey Sammi Podcast: Questions Sports Parents Actually Ask

Playing time. Quitting mid-season. Difficult coaches. Sideline drama. I answer the real questions you're dealing with every week. Got one of your own? Email me at hey@heysammi.com. Your question might be answered on the show.

Browse all episodes →